Buying debt as an investment in the US: returns, risks and how to start

26 de May de 2025 Debtalia
Buying debt as an investment in the US: returns, risks and how to start

While some people want to shed their unpaid receivables, others have turned them into a business. Buying debt at a discount is one of the most profitable alternative investments when done properly.

The business model

It is simple: buy a receivable for a fraction of its face value (say 40 cents on the dollar) and recover more — by negotiating a partial settlement, enforcing a judgment, or waiting for the debtor's finances to improve. The spread between what you paid and what you recover, minus costs, is your return.

Example: you buy a $15,000 debt backed by a judgment for $6,000. If you recover $12,000 through a bank levy and wage garnishment, the gross return is 100% on capital invested.

Who buys debt in the US?

From large funds acquiring bank portfolios to law firms and collection attorneys buying individual accounts to enforce with their own resources, plus specialized small investors. You do not need to be a fund — many deals fall between $2,000 and $50,000 face value.

Four keys to valuing a deal

  1. The debtor's real solvency: check business status, real estate, liens and bankruptcy history before offering.
  2. Documentary quality: insist on seeing the invoices, contract or judgment before signing.
  3. Legal status: is there a judgment? Any recorded lien? Is enforcement already underway?
  4. Statute of limitations: confirm the account is not time-barred under the relevant state's law.

Risks to weigh

The obvious one is not recovering your capital if the debtor is insolvent. Add legal costs if you must litigate, long timelines, and the compliance burden of the FDCPA if you collect from consumers. Read the rules at ftc.gov (FDCPA). Diversifying across several smaller deals reduces the risk.

How to start on Debtalia

Debtalia is a marketplace that connects buyers directly with sellers — no intermediary owns the debt and there is no commission on the sale. In our listings you will find debts and portfolios with their amount, price, debt type, state and available documentation, and you contact the seller directly to make an offer.

➜ See debts for sale now

Prefer to be on the other side of the table? You can also list a debt for sale whenever you need liquidity.

¿Te deben dinero?, vende la deuda

Publica tu deuda o cartera en debtalia.com desde sólo 19,90€ y recibe ofertas de inversores.

Vender mi deuda

Artículos relacionados

What documents do you need to sell a debt in the US (ranked by value)
What documents do you need to sell a debt in the US (ranked by value)

No paperwork, no market: documentation is the first thing a debt buyer checks. A complete checklist …

22/08/2025
Tax implications of selling a debt in the US: what you should know
Tax implications of selling a debt in the US: what you should know

Selling a debt below face value has tax consequences worth understanding: the bad-debt deduction, ho…

31/07/2025
Statute of limitations on debt by state: how it affects sale value
Statute of limitations on debt by state: how it affects sale value

A time-barred debt is worth almost nothing. We explain how state statutes of limitations work, what …

09/07/2025